Duct Tape, Child Abuse and Public Education

Yesterday, on CNN, I caught this video . The incident happened in Oakridge, Oregon. Apparently, a teacher used duct tape to tape a 9-year-old boy to his chair. The news story does not tell the teacher's side of the story. The mother, the child and the superintendent are interviewed. The teacher is on paid administrative leave, pending an investigation. The Seattle Times reports the incident here and KMTR here:
Nine-year-old Austin Faile admits he was bored, and says the teacher repeatedly told him to sit down.

[...]

[Becky]Faile says she immediately called an attorney, and the school.
--sigh-- The story resonates with me on a personal level, as I had a similar experience with my son when he was in kindergarten. His teacher not only taped him to his chair, she taped his mouth shut too -- on more than one occasion. Was I horrified or outraged? No. Why? Because I lived with my son and could fully understand that when a teacher has 20+ kids in a class, she doesn't have time to deal with one that is creating havoc. As a concerned parent, I knew it was my responsibility to discover why my son was exhibiting behavior problems and by the time he was in first grade we had discovered he had dyslexia and a severe muscular coordination problem in his eyes. Once we started dealing with his physical impairments his behavior improved immensely. The International Dyslexia Association estimates that 15%-20% of the population are afflicted with dyslexia. I don't know that 9-year-old Austin from the news clip has a learning disability, but I do think that it is the parents responsibility to discover why their son is disruptive. Should the teacher lose her job? Is taping a child to a chair child abuse?

Comments

I had a teacher

who threatened to get a seatbelt for my school desk when I was in 6th grade ;-) I had a small problem with wondering around, probably due to boredom too. I can sympathize with teachers, especially when they are dealing with kids who can be on the disruptive side, but I don't see the tape as being a good solution. On the other side, if the media reports are accurate (and that is a big if), the mother seems to be more concerned that her son was humiliated in front of peers than anything else. I agree with you that it might be a case where he could benefit from testing to see if there is something else going on.

When I was in third grade..I had a teacher

grab my forehead hair(bangs) and yank.... I don't remember what I did but I remember how my eyes smarted....geez that hurt. So when we are kids and teachers whom we pretty much look up to pull our hair...tell us about needing a seat belt...etc.. it makes an impression and stays with us for life. I will say that I instructed my son's elementary school that if at any time he needed a paddling or paddling like discipline..let me know. I will do it..but no one else. The school didn't like it...but it is my responsibility to discipline, period!

Physical tape and psychic tape

I was fascinated Roxy, about how you found your son had PHYSICAL disabilities that were treatable. He must have felt incredibly frustrated in school. I don't know when this might have occurred, but things I have read suggest to me that the preferred way to handle disruptive kids today is with a ritalin (or similar) package. I think that too often disruptive children are given a snap ADD diagnosis when other factors might be involved, such as the case with your son. Parents are pressured by harassed school authorities to agree giving them the medication, a kind of psychic-taping in my opinion.
carol

We knew he was

extremely bright, and his attention span was excellent if you could engage him. But even at home we knew something was just not right. His doctors didn't catch the problem, but when I had him in to the optomitrist for an eye exam before he started first grade, they referred me to a vision specialist at Pacific University. The duct tape incident did make a lasting impression on my son, to hear him tell it it happened every day. :) But it was also effective. Here's a little update on the story from the Examiner. They quote the mother:
"Of course boys are going to be up wandering around, unless they're the odd little nerdy ones."

[snip]

"But we do plan to get a lawyer," she said. "And we're going to have to hire a psychiatrist. We don't want him to have a complex about school."
The school district is supposed to make a ruling sometime today ... ----- ePMedia ... get the scoop with us!
If it's true that our species is alone in the universe, then I'd have to say that the universe aimed rather low and settled for very little. ~ George Carlin
ePMedia ... get the scoop with us!
If it's true that our species is alone in the universe, then I'd have to say that the universe aimed rather low and settled for very little. ~ George Carlin<

Comment viewing options

Select your preferred way to display the comments and click "Save settings" to activate your changes.