Strait of Hormuz

A Hitchhiker's Guilde to the Persian Gulf

promoted - cho

If you are familiar with the trilogy "The Hitchhiker's Guide to the Galaxy", you know the Guide often packs great wisdom into a couple words. We needn't read very far in the trilogy to find sage advice regarding last week's naval encounter in the Gulf. The words "Don't Panic" appear on its cover, after all, and in large friendly letters. If you're in the mood for a hitchhiker's attempt to make sense of recent events in the Gulf, then slam down a Gargle-Blaster, pocket a scoop of peanuts, and grab your towel. It is easy to see why people are worried over this incident. President Bush is far too eager to start wars on far too feeble pretexts. Worry here is a healthy state of mind. Panic is, not so much. Unfortunately, this event got off to a panicy start thanks to several "Tonkin Gulf II" blogs. These bloggers meant well, but their conclusions are based much more on emotion than reason. Now is a time to Not Panic.

Iran Aweigh (Again)

The story of the incident between U.S. and Iranian naval forces in the Strait of Hormuz Monday morning may tell us more about the nature of today's news reporting than about the prospects for war and peace in the Middle East. Veteran military reporter Robert Burns's account of the incident for the Associated Press opened with a bang:

An Iranian fleet of boats charged at and threatened to blow up a three-ship U.S. Navy convoy passing near Iranian waters and then fled as American commanders were preparing to open fire.
The lead paragraph by Andrew Grey of Reuters sounded eerily similar:
Iranian boats aggressively approached three U.S. Naval ships in the Strait of Hormuz, a main shipping route for Gulf oil, at the weekend and threatened that the ships would explode, U.S. officials said on Monday.
Even more alarming was the top of the article in The Australian:
A Pentagon official said that US forces were "literally" on the verge of firing on the Iranian boats as they passed through the strategic Strait of Hormuz, and had moved to man their guns when the Iranians turned and sped away.

What Does Iran Have to Gain Here?

The answer, as far as I can think of, is nothing, and there is pretty much everything to lose.

This is why I reacted to the report that Iranian boats had “provoked” US ships in the Strait of Hormuz with a “WTF????”. Let’s look at a few things here, just to make heads or tails of things.

GreyHawk's picture

They Dare Us To Watch It Happen

This just in, via Reuters:
Five Iranian Revolutionary Guard boats harassed and provoked three U.S. Navy ships in the Strait of Hormuz, a major oil shipping route off the Iranian coast, during the weekend, Pentagon officials said on Monday. [...snip...] According to the officials, the radio transmission from one of the Iranian ships said: "I am coming at you. You will explode in a couple of minutes." The officials said it was not unusual for Iranian boats to get close to U.S. ships in the strait but the radio transmission was unusual.
I'll bet. It appears to be a direct attempt at provocation, doesn't it?